#118: Jessica Katz’s Rental Arbitrage Journey

by | Feb 4, 2025 | Podcast

FEBRUARY 04, 2025

#118: Turning Setbacks Into Success: Jessica Katz’s Rental Arbitrage Journey

How Jessica Katz Built a Thriving Short-Term Rental Business Without Owning Property

Have you ever wondered how you can break into the short-term rental business without actually owning real estate? Jessica Katz’s incredible rental arbitrage journey is packed with inspiration, grit, and actionable strategies that prove it’s possible to build a profitable rental empire from scratch.

After a devastating setback in her medical career, she made a bold pivot into real estate. With no prior experience, she tackled the challenging world of rental arbitrage—securing leases, designing irresistible spaces, and stacking up serious profits. But the road wasn’t easy. Jessica faced 77 rejections before landing her first deal!

In this episode, she shares her most valuable lessons on securing rental properties, working with apartment complexes, and making strategic investments in design and furnishings. Whether you’re considering rental arbitrage or looking to scale your existing business, Jessica’s insights will give you the tools and confidence to make it happen.

What is Rental Arbitrage, and Why Does It Work?

Rental arbitrage is the strategy of leasing a property and then listing it on short-term rental platforms like Airbnb and Vrbo for a profit. It allows entrepreneurs like Jessica to scale a real estate business without the massive capital required to buy property.

Jessica breaks down the fundamentals of rental arbitrage and explains how she built a 24-unit portfolio using strategic negotiations, creative problem-solving, and relentless determination. She also sheds light on key considerations when working with landlords, apartment complexes, and single-family homes.

Key Takeaways from Jessica Katz’s Rental Arbitrage Journey:

[00:01] Jessica shares how she found rental arbitrage and why she saw it as her ticket to financial freedom.

[09:16] After experiencing career instability, Jessica reveals how she managed stress, stayed motivated, and remained focused on building her business.

[15:57] From rejection after rejection, Jessica explains how she pushed past obstacles and kept moving forward.

[21:34] Jessica discusses the specific strategies she used to finally secure her first deal after 77 rejections.

[23:53] She shares her methods for convincing apartment complexes to allow rental arbitrage and the advantages of this approach.

[28:08] Jessica weighs the pros and cons of arbitraging apartment units versus single-family properties.

[32:20]  Jessica reveals her approach to upgrading and furnishing properties to stand out from the competition.

[35:26] She explains how she allocates budget for furnishing each property while ensuring it remains profitable.

[38:22] Rapid-fire insights on Jessica’s journey, biggest lessons, and advice for aspiring rental arbitrage entrepreneurs.

Golden Nuggets

  • “What helped me the most was finding something to be able to rely on if the worst-case scenario happened again.”
  • “We can do anything as women, as long as we believe in ourselves and we’re intentional about how we focus our time, energy, and efforts.”
  • “If you follow the guides that have worked for other people, and you are willing to put in the time it takes to learn how to analyze the right property and do all the right things, you can be successful in this.”

Ready to Start Your Own Rental Arbitrage Business?

Jessica’s journey proves that setbacks can be the foundation of a stronger comeback. Her step-by-step approach to rental arbitrage offers a clear roadmap for anyone looking to break into the short-term rental space without owning property.

From finding the right deals to creating spaces that attract guests, Jessica’s insights are invaluable. Whether you’re starting from scratch or looking to scale, her strategies will help you build a profitable short-term rental business.

CONNECT WITH OUR GUEST

Enjoyed the show? Subscribe, Rate, Review, Like, and Share!

The Latest…

#156  Unreasonable Hospitality with Candice Menard

#156 Unreasonable Hospitality with Candice Menard

OCTOBER 28, 2025  #156  Unreasonable Hospitality: How Candice Menard Is Transforming the Short-Term Rental ExperienceWhat if standing out in the short-term rental industry isn’t just about the property—but the experience you create? In a world where guests are flooded...

#155 Ashley Freeman’s Short-Term Rental Success

#155 Ashley Freeman’s Short-Term Rental Success

OCTOBER 21, 2025  #155  Short-Term Rental Success: How Ashley Freeman Built a 115-Property EmpireHow do you rebuild your life—and create extraordinary success—after everything falls apart? In this episode, I sit down with Ashley Freeman, a former tennis pro who turned...

#154 Building Wealth Through Short-Term Rentals

#154 Building Wealth Through Short-Term Rentals

OCTOBER 14, 2025  #154  Building Wealth Through Short-Term Rentals: How Zoey Berghoff Turned a Tiny Dome Into a Real Estate EmpireCould a 300-square-foot glamping dome really be the start of a real estate empire? For Zoey Berghoff, the answer is a resounding yes. In...

#153 Abundance Mindset for STR Growth

#153 Abundance Mindset for STR Growth

OCTOBER 07, 2025  #153 Abundance Mindset for STR Growth: Mindset Shifts That Boost Your RevenueWhat if the biggest barrier to growing your short-term rental business isn’t strategy, listings, or even money—but your mindset? That’s exactly the lesson Esmeralda Alba...